Best Bottle for Breastfed Baby Who Refuses Bottle: 11 Expert Picks

Disclosure: I may get commissions when you click through the affiliate links (that are great products I stand by) on my articles. You can read the full disclosure for more information. Content is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice.

Finding the best bottle for a breastfed baby who refuses bottle can feel like a quest. It’s all about mimicking that natural breastfeeding feel to make the transition smoother.

As a breastfeeding mom and breastfeeding counselor, I’ve learned that the bottle’s nipple shape, flow rate, and material are pivotal in recreating the breastfeeding experience for younger babies. Plus, let’s not forget the importance of ease of use, cleaning, and safety standards.

Dive into our curated list, crafted after meticulous research and testing of different bottles, to discover the ideal bottle for your little one, ensuring joyful feedings ahead.

Best bottle for breastfed baby who refuses bottle

Oh, the joys of parenthood – and dealing with a stubborn, bottle-refusing baby! Fear not, weary parents, for we have gathered a list of the best bottles designed to woo even the most resistant little ones. Let the breast milk flow and the babies be nourished with our top picks below.

Here is the full list:

1. Lansinoh Baby Bottles for Breastfeeding Babies, 5 Ounces, 3 Count
2. Comotomo Baby Bottle, Green
3. Tommee Tippee Closer To Nature Baby Bottles
4. MAM Easy Start Anti Colic Baby Bottle 5 oz
5. Nanobébé Flexy Silicone Baby Bottle
6. Boon NURSH Reusable Silicone Baby Bottles
7. Dr. Brown’s Natural Flow Anti-Colic Options+Wide-Neck Baby Bottle
8. Philips AVENT Anti-Colic Baby Bottles
9. Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Silicone Baby Bottle
10. Dr. Brown’s Natural Flow Anti-Colic Options+ Narrow Baby Bottles
11. Haakaa Gen.3 Natural Glass Baby Bottle 4.2oz

1. TOP PICK: Lansinoh Baby Bottles for Breastfeeding Babies, 5 Ounces, 3 Count

These Lansinoh Baby Bottles are a game-changer for breastfed babies who refuse the bottle, making feedings smoother and more enjoyable for many babies.

As we started using the Lansinoh Baby Bottles, we noticed that the NaturalWave Nipple truly made a difference in our little one’s feeding experience. The nipple is designed to simulate a natural breastfeeding feel, which helped our baby transition more easily between breast and bottle – a lifesaver!

The air ventilation system in the nipple is quite innovative, as it helps reduce the intake of air, which could often lead to colic or spit up. Although we found the vent system effective, others may not have had the same positive experience.

Ease of cleaning and use is essential when dealing with baby products, and these bottles did not disappoint. With only four pieces to clean, we had no issue quickly disassembling, washing, and putting them back together. We should note, however, that while the bottles are compatible with most bottle warmers, they may not fit all sizes or styles, so double-check before purchasing.

Overall, these Lansinoh Baby Bottles have made a significant positive impact on our breastfed baby’s feeding experience. With a design that promotes natural feeding actions, an air ventilation system, and ease of use, these bottles are definitely worth considering for most breastfed babies who refuse the bottle. Just make sure the vent system works for you and keep an eye on the nipple sizes when purchasing.

2. Comotomo Baby Bottle, Green

We think this bottle is a top choice for breastfed babies who refuse bottles due to its thoughtful design and natural feel.

We have been using the Comotomo Baby Bottle and were truly impressed by its innovative features. Its design closely mimics natural breastfeedingTo help a baby breastfeed when they won’t take a bottle, offer expressed breastmilk in a bottle, use a rocking chair for comfort, and introduce the bottle when the baby is calm but not too hungry.The naturally shaped, soft silicone material has a skin-like texture that our baby loved to hold.

Cleaning this bottle is a breeze! Thanks to its ultra-wide-neck design, we can easily clean it without using a brush. It’s also safe to use in the microwave, boiling water, dishwashers, and sterilizers. We’ve had no issues regarding leaking, and the dual anti-colic vents prevented unwanted air intake, reducing colic for our baby.

However, we found that the milk takes a bit longer to warm up due to the silicone material. Additionally, the nipple flow may be too slow for some older babies, and our baby struggled a bit initially.

Overall, we have had a delightful experience using the Comotomo Baby Bottle. If your breastfed baby won’t take bottles, this one is definitely worth a try. Its innovative design and natural feel could be the answer you are looking for to make feeding time enjoyable for both you and your little one.

3. Tommee Tippee Closer To Nature Baby Bottles

These Tommee Tippee bottles have our vote for babies refusing the bottle, with their breast-like design and anti-colic features.

We recently tried out the Tommee Tippee Closer To Nature Baby Bottles, and we have to say, they’re quite impressive when it comes to helping breastfed babies accept the bottle. The soft silicone nipple is designed to mimic a mother’s breast, which encourages a natural latch and helps prevent nipple confusion when switching between breastfeeding and bottle feeding. Our baby fed comfortably at their own pace, and we noticed fewer issues with colic, thanks to the innovative anti-colic valve.

However, we must admit, not all babies might share the same enthusiasm for these bottles. Some might prefer other designs, and we observed that the nipple can sometimes be pushed into the bottle. Nevertheless, these issues were rather rare, and the overall experience was still quite pleasant.

The bottles come in a limited range of colors, which can be a drawback for parents who prefer more variety. But on the brighter side, they’re easy to clean and 100% leakproof, ensuring a mess-free feeding experience even when turned upside down or shaken. This practical bottle design is definitely worth giving a try for breastfed babies who refuse the bottle.

So, fellow parents, if you’re looking for a bottle to make the switch smoother and address colic issues, the Tommee Tippee Closer To Nature Baby Bottles have got your back (and your baby’s tummy)!

4. MAM Easy Start Anti Colic Baby Bottle 5 oz

We absolutely recommend the MAM Easy Start Anti Colic Baby Bottle for fussy breastfed babies who refuse the bottle, thanks to its innovative design and nipple shape.

As we’ve used the MAM Easy Start Anti Colic Baby Bottle with our little one, we’ve noticed how the elongated nipple shape truly feels just like mom’s breast. This design helps our breastfed baby to switch easily between breastfeeding and bottle feeding, without any fuss or any bottle refusal.

Thanks to MAM’s vented base design, we observed that this bottle releases liquid slowly, which indeed reduced colic symptoms in our baby by eliminating gas-causing bubbles. Knowing that 80%* of babies show improved colic symptoms using this bottle really gives us peace of mind, making it worth every penny.

*Field study, Austria 2011, tested with 73 mothers of colicky babies / Market research, USA 2010, tested with 35 mothers of colicky babies. 

What we also love about this MAM bottle is that it’s self-sterilizing in the microwave. No need for a separate bottle sterilizer! We simply add 20ml of water in the base, assemble the bottle, and heat it in the microwave for 3 minutes. In addition, it is made from BPS and BPA free materials, which is a great bonus.

However, a word of caution: if the white rubber base is missing or not properly aligned, the bottle can leak. Also, keep in mind that there are multiple parts to clean. But all in all, we firmly stand by the benefits of the MAM Easy Start Anti Colic Baby Bottle for breastfed babies who refuse bottles.

5. Nanobébé Flexy Silicone Baby Bottle

We highly recommend this bottle for breastfed babies who refuse others, as it makes feeding time a breeze!

Our experience with the Nanobébé Flexy Silicone Baby Bottle has shown us that it can truly make the difference for a breastfed baby who refuses other bottles. The extra-soft, familiar nipple helped our little one latch on easily, with no nipple confusion. The soft texture of the bottle also makes it comfortable for both us and baby during feeding time.

Thanks to the advanced 360° triple vented design, our baby experienced significantly less fussiness, gassiness, and discomfort after feeding. The transition between breastfeeding and bottle feeding became seamless, and we were genuinely impressed by the bottle’s ability to mimic a natural feeding experience.

Although the bottle works wonderfully for most types of feeds, we found that it might not be the best choice for very thick, high viscosity feeds. Additionally, the available nipple sizes are somewhat limited, so if your baby’s mouth requires a different size, it might be challenging to find the perfect fit. Also, it’s worth noting that the snap-on bottle handles, designed to help your baby develop fine motor skills, are sold separately.

Overall, we believe that the Nanobébé Flexy Silicone Baby Bottle is a fantastic choice for breastfed babies who refuse typical bottles. It offers convenience, a natural feel, and hassle-free feeding sessions, making it a must-have addition to your baby feeding essentials.

6. Boon NURSH Reusable Silicone Baby Bottles

We highly recommend these bottles for any parent struggling with a breastfed baby who refuses a bottle – Boon NURSH is a game changer!

We’ve tried numerous bottles, but trust us, the Boon NURSH Reusable Silicone Baby Bottles take the cake! Let us explain why. The unique air-free feeding design eliminates the need for complicated straws, valves, and vents, making it so much easier to clean and assemble. The silicone pouch collapses as our little one drinks, squeezing out the gas-inducing air that causes colic. It’s a real lifesaver!

The moment we held these bottles, we were impressed by their 100% silicone pouch construction. Not only does this material help avoid contact with harmful substances, but it also allows the bottles to be boiled, sterilized, microwaved, and frozen — talk about versatile!

When it comes to replicating that natural breastfeeding feel, Boon NURSH Bottles have nailed it. Their design encourages proper tongue positioning, making it easy for our baby to latch on quickly. However, we noticed that if we didn’t line up the pouch with the silicone correctly, it could cause some spills. Also, they occasionally leaked if not screwed on properly, but that’s something we quickly learned to manage.

Don’t let the slightly higher price tag deter you from investing in these fantastic bottles. Boon NURSH Reusable Silicone Baby Bottles are an outstanding choice for babies who struggle to transition from breastfeeding, and they’re worth every penny!

7. Dr. Brown’s Natural Flow Anti-Colic Options+Wide-Neck Baby Bottle

We highly recommend Dr. Brown’s Natural Flow Anti-Colic Options+ Wide-Neck Baby Bottle for breastfed babies who refuse the bottle, as it eases the transition and offers a comfortable feeding experience.

We recently tried Dr. Brown’s Natural Flow Anti-Colic Options+ Wide-Neck Baby Bottle, and we truly appreciate its breast-like nipple shape, which encourages a proper latch for a more natural feeding experience. This bottle has made it much easier for us to transition between breastfeeding and bottle feeding.

The clinically-proven anti-colic internal vent system has worked wonders with our baby; it significantly reduces colic, spit-up, burping, and gas. We’ve also noticed that the preserved nutrients and improved digestion have led to better sleep for our little one.

However, we noticed a couple of drawbacks. The silicone nipple may sometimes collapse when our baby holds the bottle, making feeding a bit difficult. Additionally, cleaning the bottle can be a bit challenging due to its design. Be cautious when handling the bottle, as it may leak if not properly assembled or held.

Overall, we find that Dr. Brown’s Natural Flow Anti-Colic Options+ Wide-Neck Baby Bottle is an excellent choice for breastfed babies who refuse the bottle. It has its minor flaws, but the benefits outweigh them, making it an essential item for a comfortable feeding experience and a smooth transition between breastfeeding and bottle feeding.

8. Philips AVENT Anti-Colic Baby Bottles

We recommend Philips AVENT Anti-Colic Baby Bottles for fussy breastfed babies, as it helps reduce colic, gas, and reflux effectively.

Our firsthand experience with the Philips AVENT Anti-Colic Baby Bottles has been mostly positive. We noticed a significant reduction in colic, gas, and reflux symptoms, making feeding time much more enjoyable for both us and the little one. The AirFree vent kept the nipple full of milk and not air, allowing for easy upright feeding—an excellent bonus for reducing reflux.

Despite the fantastic benefits, our breastfed baby took a few tries to get accustomed to the nipple shape. We also faced a bit of a learning curve with adjusting to the slow flow of the anti-colic insert. In the end, the positive changes these bottles brought to our feeding routine outweighed these minor issues.

The ease of cleaning and assembling the Philips AVENT Anti-Colic Baby Bottles was much appreciated, especially given the numerous tasks that come with parenthood. We highly recommend this bottle set for parents who want to make feeding time less of a struggle for both bottle fed and breastfed babies.

9. Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Silicone Baby Bottle

You should consider this bottle if you want a soft, breast-like experience for your baby that helps with colic.

We recently tried the Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Silicone Baby Bottle, and we were quite impressed by its design and functionality. The soft-touch, skin-like silicone feels just like mom providing our baby with the familiar warmth of our breast. Our baby transitioned easily between the bottle and breastfeeding, thanks to the breast-like shape of the nipples.

The addition of an anti-colic valve in the nipple was a game-changer for us. It helped reduce the symptoms of colic by preventing excessive air from getting into our baby’s milk. The soft silicone nipple also allowed our baby to feed comfortably at their own pace, flexing and stretching just like our breast.

However, we did face some challenges with the bottle. The volume markings on it are nearly impossible to read without a flashlight or bright light, making it less suitable for night-time feedings. Additionally, the bottle comes with a slow flow nipple suitable for 0+ months, so if your baby needs a faster flow, you’ll need to purchase additional nipples separately.

In conclusion, the Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Silicone Baby Bottle provides a natural, breast-like experience for your baby while helping with colic symptoms. But keep in mind the difficulty in reading the volume markings and the need to purchase additional nipples for faster flow rates. Overall, we believe it’s a great option for parents looking for a seamless transition between bottle and breastfeeding.

10. Dr. Brown’s Natural Flow Anti-Colic Options+ Narrow Baby Bottles

We believe these Dr. Brown’s bottles are an outstanding choice for breastfed babies who refuse other bottles, as they tackle colic and enhance the overall feeding experience.

Our hands-on experience with Dr. Brown’s Natural Flow Anti-Colic Options+ Narrow Baby Bottles has left us quite impressed. One of the critical factors we noticed is the anti-colic internal vent system, which is clinically proven to alleviate colic and minimize issues like spit-up, burping, and gas. Compared to other bottles we’ve tried, it provides a comfortable feeding experience for the baby.

Furthermore, the vacuum-free feeding and silicone nipples are designed to mimic the natural breastfeeding experience. The flow is consistent, and the nipple shape encourages proper latching, making the transition between breast and bottle smooth and hassle-free. We appreciate this feature, as breastfed babies often refuse other bottles due to the difference in flow and latching experience.

On the downside, we’ve found that the vent system, while effective, does require some extra cleaning effort compared to simpler bottles. The narrow design, though helpful in minimizing air intake, might not be ideal for those who prefer Dr. Brown’s wider bottles. Additionally, the bottle may not cater to certain babies with specific latching issues that require alternative designs.

Despite these minor drawbacks, we can vouch for the quality and effectiveness of Dr. Brown’s Natural Flow Anti-Colic Options+ Narrow Baby Bottles, a worthy investment for the comfort and well-being of your breastfed baby.

11. Haakaa Gen.3 Natural Glass Baby Bottle 4.2oz

If you’re seeking a bottle for your breastfed baby who refuses bottles, the Haakaa Gen.3 Natural Glass Baby Bottle 4.2oz is the way to go.

Upon using the Haakaa Gen.3 Natural Glass Baby Bottle, we were impressed by how closely it mimicked the shape of a mother’s nipple during breastfeeding. This off-centre orthodontic thumb-shaped silicone teat was superb in providing our little one with the most natural feeding experience possible. The wide neck and ergonomic design made the bottle a breeze to hold and clean, as well as fill with breastmilk or formula.

One of the best features of this Haakaa baby bottle is the use of pure borosilicate glass, which makes the bottle temperature-resistant. This feature was especially convenient since we were able to heat and freeze the bottle without worrying about its safety. Moreover, it also made storing our expressed breast milk easy.

However, there were a few drawbacks we noticed with the Haakaa glass bottle. Its high price point may not be suitable for all budgets, especially given how fast babies grow. Additionally, getting the top screwed on just right can be a bit tricky at times – if not positioned correctly, the bottle may leak. Lastly, despite being made of sturdy glass, we found it to be thinner than we expected.

In conclusion, the Haakaa Gen.3 Natural Glass Baby Bottle definitely provides the most natural feeding experience for breastfed babies who refuse bottles. The ergonomic design and material safety make it a solid choice for parents. However, the higher price point and potential leaking may be something to consider when making your decision.

Buying guide

Navigating the bottle aisle can feel like a maze, especially when your little one is a discerning diner. But with the right pointers, you’ll be on the path to success in no time.

1. Nipple nuances

• Shape: Seek a bottle nipple that’s a doppelganger for a real breast. It’s all about making the switch seamless.
• Flow: Newborns thrive with slow-flow nipples. As they grow, you can introduce them to the thrill of faster flows.

2. Material matters

• Plastic: Light, durable, and perfect for the ‘drop-it-and-watch-mom-pick-it-up’ game. Just keep an eye on wear and tear.
• Glass: Robust, eco-friendly, and a champ at staying odor-free. They’re a tad heavier and demand gentle handling.

Table: Plastic vs. Glass Bottles

3. Bonus features

• Venting Systems: Less air means less gas. A content, burp-free baby? Priceless.
• Easy Cleaning: Time is gold. Opt for bottles that won’t have you scrubbing for ages.
• Ergonomic Designs: For those tiny hands to grip and master the art of self-feeding.

Embarking on this bottle quest? Armed with this guide, you’re set to find that game-changing bottle for your discerning breastfed star. Happy feeding!

The bridge between breastfeeding and pumping

While finding the best bottle for a breastfed baby who’s a bit resistant is crucial, it’s equally essential to consider the source of that milk: the pump. For many moms, pumping becomes an integral part of the breastfeeding journey, especially when balancing work, personal time, and feeding.

If you’re diving into the world of pumping, there are a few resources on our blog that you might find invaluable:

• Elvie vs. Willow: The modern mom’s dilemma. Dive into our detailed Elvie and Willow comparison to discover which pump reigns supreme.
• Combining Breastfeeding and Pumping: It’s both an art and a science. Learn the best strategies to integrate breastfeeding and pumping seamlessly into your routine.
• Pumping at Work: Balancing professionalism with pumping can be a challenge, but with the right tips, it becomes a breeze. Discover our top advice for pumping at work.
• Smart Breast Pumps: In the age of tech, even breast pumps have gone smart. Find out the best smart breast pumps in the market.
• Wearable Breast Pumps: For the mom on-the-go, wearable pumps are a game-changer. Explore the best wearable breast pump options.

Remember, whether you’re breastfeeding, pumping, or both, the journey is uniquely yours. Embrace it, and know that every drop of milk, every bottle offered, and every pump session is a testament to your love and dedication.

Breastfed baby bottle refusal FAQs

Generated with Pin Generator